MLB Picks & Predictions — Tuesday, May 12, 2026 | SharpBetz

Tuesday, May 12, 2026

MLB Predictions and Expert Picks

AI-powered MLB picks with confidence ratings. How our model works · Track record

Confidence All Low (<60%) Medium (60-75%) High (>75%)

MLB Picks 6

Washington 19-22 (6-13)

Cincinnati 22-19 (12-9)

SPR TOT +1.5 O 9.5 -1.5 U 9.5

SPR TOT ML +1.5 O 9.5 +124 -1.5 U 9.5 -149

SPR TOT ML +3.7 O 10.4 +274 -3.7 U 10.4 -274

Detroit 19-22 (12-6)

New York 15-25 (6-12)

SPR TOT +1.5 O 7.5 -1.5 U 7.5

SPR TOT ML +1.5 O 7.5 +119 -1.5 U 7.5 -143

SPR TOT ML +3.2 O 8.4 +240 -3.2 U 8.4 -240

Chicago 27-14 (18-5)

Atlanta 28-13 (12-6)

SPR TOT -1.5 O 8.5 +1.5 U 8.5

SPR TOT ML -1.5 O 8.5 +102 +1.5 U 8.5 -122

SPR TOT ML +3.6 O 7.5 +263 -3.6 U 7.5 -263

Miami 19-22 (14-12)

Minnesota 18-23 (10-10)

SPR TOT -1.5 O 9 +1.5 U 9

SPR TOT ML -1.5 O 9 -115 +1.5 U 9 -105

SPR TOT ML +3.4 O 9.4 +253 -3.4 U 9.4 -253

San Diego 24-16 (13-10)

Milwaukee 22-16 (13-8)

SPR TOT +1.5 O 9 -1.5 U 9

SPR TOT ML +1.5 O 9 +124 -1.5 U 9 -149

SPR TOT ML +3.4 O 7.9 +254 -3.4 U 7.9 -254

St. Louis 23-17 (10-10)

Athletics 21-19 (8-8)

SPR TOT +1.5 O 10 -1.5 U 10

SPR TOT ML +1.5 O 10 +129 -1.5 U 10 -156

SPR TOT ML +3.4 O 9.1 +248 -3.4 U 9.1 -248